In our monthly independent review of branded recommerce, we take a look at which brands and retailers launched resale programs and the potential impact on the planet.

BRANDS WITH RESALE SHOPS

TOTAL RESALE SHOP LISTINGS

YOY RESALE SHOP GROWTH

 
RankBrandResale Shop Listings
September 2023
Listings Change
vs August 2023
Resale Shop Launch Year
1Patagonia41,762+4,5022017
2Tea Collection22,900-602022
3Athleta20,059-1,7452022
4American Eagle19,483-4,2092023
5Princess Polly17,646+4702022
6Madewell14,764-5,3602021
7Lululemon Athletica13,652+1182021
8Hanna Andersson12,432+7202023
9H&M11,332-5,0752023
10Eileen Fisher9,926-6292009
11Journeys9,727-3,1662023
12J.Crew6,877-2,1332023
13REI6,174-1,4802017
14Tommy Hilfiger4,189-1,4482022
15Fabletics | Yitty3,737-1,2222023
16PacSun2,212-2592022
17Girlfriend Collective2,070+1082023
18The North Face1,978-1772018
19The Beaufort Bonnet Company1,688+1382022
20Kate Spade1,679-2792023
21Carhartt 1,533+6982023
22Rylee + Cru1,356+1102022
23Arc'teryx1,318+982019
24Michael Stars1,290-3272022
25ON1,159+2292022
26M.M.LaFleur1,152+482021
27Allbirds1,063+1902022
28NIC + ZOE1,028-2112023
29Canada Goose974+582023
30Vera Bradley949-3872022
31Steve Madden872+3222022
32jujube820-642022
33Roolee798-132022
34Brooks Running776+22023
35Faherty748+692023
36Outerknown742-232021
36Cuts742+932022
38Ulla Johnson651+232023
39MooseJaw611+2232023
40Sam Edelman537+152023
41Sandro530+22022
42Ba&sh528+482023
43Connected Apparel507-1732023
44DVF480+472023
45NATION LTD475-1822022
46TOMS448-1932023
47SoulCycle446-1192023
48Bohemian Mama408-82022
49Toad & Co376+302023
50Nooworks374+122021
51Maaji364+742022
52Coclico345+172021
53Ministry of Supply341-602022
54Frye303-42022
55Sarah Flint274+262022
56Francesca's269-872022
56HOBO269-112023
58Michael Kors260+132022
59Levi's258+482020
60Electric Yoga255+112023
61Amour Vert250-302021
62Hot Topic245-342022
63Vitality243+872023
64Elizabeth Suzann Studio237+312022
65Modcloth226+462022
65Smartwool226+2262023NEW
67CROSBY by Mollie Burch198+222023
68James Street Co.196+862022
69Rachel Comey192-72021
70Sozy184-152021
71Misha & Puff176-322021
72Ziabird168+802022
73Rough & Tumble158+322022
73Wolven158+702021
75For Love & Lemons148+172023
76Apiece Apart142+1422023NEW
77Allegra James138+1382023NEW
78Vetta135-162022
79Nui Organics131+1312023NEW
80Muse Threads128+1282023NEW
81Stio124-562021
82Brass122-192020
83Ariat118+142023
84Tuesday of California116+152022
85Tentree112+282022
86Oak + Fort111-162022
86Los Angeles Apparel111-142022
86Boyish111-12021
89Kyrgies11002022
90Bryr10902022
90Fortress109+22021
927 For All Mankind108+142022
93HELM Boots107-22022
94Myles105-32022
95minnow100+102021
96Koral98+92022
97Donni 97+192023
98Dagne Dover9602021
98Youer96+52022
98Djerf Avenue96+182022
101Mara Hoffman95+252021
102Meg94-182023
103La Ligne81+82021
104Polarn O. Pyret77-282022
105Oscar De La Renta75+302021
105A.L.C.75+752023NEW
107Teeki Boutique67-202023
108Clare V.63+152022
109Bernardo62-692022
110Seaesta Surf61-22021
110Kirrin Finch61+172022
112Sur La Cote5702022
112SuperX57+572023NEW
114Cuyana53+12022
114Wayre53+102022
116Whimsy + Row51-32022
117Modern Citizen50-242023
1173.1 Phillip Lim5002022
119Better Life Bags48+72022
120Ophelia & Indigo47-102022
121Hey Gang46+32022
122Ponto43-32022
123Lisa Says Gah41-32023
123Saylor41-22022
123Iksplor41-12022
126Wrangler40+12022
126State40+12022
126époque évolution40+72020
129DL196138-22023
130Skhoop36+22022
131RE/DONE31+22021
132Poplinen29-12022
132Woodley + Lowe2902022
132Namai29+292023NEW
135LIVSN27+272023NEW
136Apparis22-22022
137Miakoda21-252022
138Ranch Road Boots20+12022
139Altar1902022
139Dolce Vita19+22022
141Curator SF1702022
142ALPAKA16-42023
143Wild Rye15+42022
144Kitsbow14-42023
144Pakt14+142023NEW
146Alyson Eastman1302022
147Viscata9-22022
148C1Hu8-22022
149Another Tomorrow7+32022
150Firebird622021
150Yes and622022
152Steven Alan 512023
152Juicy Couture 5+12023
154ET T/GRE402020
154BAABUK Sàrl4+02023NEW
156Lacausa0-42021
156Ecologyst0-42022

Only resale listings that are available from a brand’s e-commerce site are counted towards that brand. See methodology.

Brands’ Adoption of Resale is Accelerating

 

Circular Fashion News & Resources

  • Why everyone got sold on resale in 2022

    – Retail Brew

  • For Kate Spade, resale is a customer acquisition tool

    – Glossy

  • Branded Resale Surpasses 100 Programs and Counting, as of September

    – WWD

  • Big retailers are getting into the secondhand market. Will that change how we shop?

    – Grist

 
  • The Recommerce 100 is compiled from publicly available information to identify fashion brands selling their own brand’s pre-owned products online to US shoppers. Only resale listings that are available from a brand’s e-commerce site are counted towards that brand. Listing count includes listings managed by the brand, as well as listings by independent sellers (commonly referred to as peer-to-peer selling). A count of listings was completed between September 26 and 27, 2023. Listing count either reflects 1) the stated number of total results commonly found at the top of the first product listing page, or 2) if results are not featured on the product listing page, a manual count of all listings. Listing count is intended to be directionally representative of the size of a brand’s resale shop at a given time. There is no guarantee that our listing count is exact given the dynamic nature of e-commerce listings, sales, returns, as well as site and user experience factors. Listing counts do not include listings on third-party marketplaces (examples include thredup.com, therealreal.com, poshmark.com). thredUP Resale-as-a-Service™ clients are counted among the brands and retailers with Resale Shops (e.g. Athleta, Tommy Hilfiger, Madewell and PacSun).

    Resale shop launch year is compiled based on publicly available information from sources including statements on brand websites, media coverage, brand social media posts or inquiries to brands’ customer service.

    Estimated resale shop penetration is modeled using publicly available information on brand annual revenue, listing counts (see above listing count methodology) and a survey of listing prices.

    *Change versus resale shops identified and listings counted as of September 2023.

    Published October 2023

  • The Recommerce 100 contains estimates, based on publicly available information as of the published date of data collection expressed in the Methodology, and therefore involves a number of assumptions and limitations. thredUP has not independently verified the publicly available information and cannot guarantee accuracy or completeness of the information. Resale shop listings, resale shop launch year, estimated resale sales value (as a percent of brands’ total publicly stated revenue), and the presence of an evergreen clothing take back program (for recycling, donation, or resale) are therefore subject to a high degree of uncertainty, especially as resale is a new and rapidly changing segment. These and other factors could cause actual numbers to differ materially from those expressed. We do not guarantee that the Recommerce 100 includes every fashion brand selling its own pre-owned products online to US shoppers.

    Except as required by law, thredUP assumes no obligation to update any report after the published date of data collection. thredUP intends to publish the Recommerce 100 on a monthly basis.